
Rory O'Connor
Writing a list of great films that got nominated for the Golden Raspberry for “Worst Movie” of the year is about as easy as writing a list of awful films to be nominated for Best Picture at the Oscars—which is to say, there’s really no shortage of them to choose from.
The so-called ‘Razzies’ were first awarded at a casual dinner held by Hollywood publicist John B.Wilson in 1980, but quickly got a reputation for their tongue-in-cheek, anti-garlanding of the year’s most outlandish, hammy or financially catastrophic movies—three things that, of course, don’t always detract from a film’s quality.
In fact, in our current age of quickfire reassessment, those things are increasingly seen as badges of honour—one person’s cringey mess is another person’s camp classic, after all. So, with that in mind, here are 10 perfectly good movies (a few are only decent, but most are great!) that have been nominated for “Worst Movie” at the Razzies in the last 45 years. Read on to discover more and use the guide below to find them on services like AppleTV, Netflix, Prime Video and elsewhere.
1. Cruising (1980)
We’ll start things off with the very first year of the awards, when Stanley Donen’s cult sci-fi Saturn 3 was nominated along with the first Friday the 13th movie, and Cruising, a frankly legendary work from the great William Friedkin—and an early sign of what would soon become a puritanical trend in the anti-awards body’s annual selection process.
When Friedkin, who directed movies like The Exorcist and Sorcerer (and if you like them, be sure to give this a try), passed away in 2023, Cruising (in which Al Pacino goes undercover in the underground S&M scene in New York) seemed to be the film that most people were talking about—a provocative gem that was years ahead of its time.
2. Heaven’s Gate (1981)
When I saw Isabel Huppert give a masterclass at a film festival recently, the great French actress candidly admitted that the treatment Michael Cimino received for Heaven’s Gate broke his heart. The film is infamous for having effectively bankrupted United Artists (an independent studio known for more daring releases like One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest and In the Heat of the Night), but the film’s reputation these days is probably just as lofty among cinephiles as that of Cimino’s more celebrated earlier work, The Deer Hunter.
Set in Wyoming, Heaven’s Gate is a stunning modern Western that fans of sweeping films like Days of Heaven and Dances With Wolves will lap up.
3. Ishtar (1987)
Another in the trend of Golden Raspberry nominees that were damned for biting off more than they could chew was Elaine May’s Ishtar. This one is particularly problematic, as May was one of the only female filmmakers working in Hollywood at the time, and the treatment the Mikey and Nicky director received basically derailed her career, denying us all a lot of great films as a result. She did write the scripts for The Birdcage and Primary Colours (and if you’re a fan of those films, you might want to give this one a shot) in the ‘90s, but tragically hasn’t directed another movie since.
This probably happened because viewers at the time didn’t know what to make of the tonally jarring comedy, in which two American songwriters travel to Morocco and get embroiled in a Cold War standoff. It has, naturally, found an audience in more recent years and May has even got back in the director’s chair for the first time since with the upcoming Crackpot—though at 93 years of age, we can only hope that she can finish it on time.
4. Cocktail (1988)
Four entries into our list and we get to the first of a few actual winners of “Worst Movie” at the Razzies: the perfectly enjoyable Tom Cruise vehicle Cocktail from 1988, in which the actor (hot on the heels of Top Gun and The Colour of Money) played a cocky business student who takes up bartending to pay the bills.
Upon release, the film was hacked to pieces by critics but made a killing at the box office. It has, in its own way, also stood the test of time. If you like young Cruise, you’ll probably love it.
5. Indecent Proposal (1993)
Our next entrant is another proud winner of “Worst Movie” from the Razzies: the Robert Redford/Demi Moore erotic thriller Indecent Proposal. This is the one where a wealthy man (Redford) offers a married couple $1 million in return for one night with the wife (Moore).
Granted, for obvious reasons, this setup has not aged the best—not least for the fact that the man is played by Robert Redford, an actor so famously handsome that Mike Nichols refused to hire him for The Graduate after confirming he had never “struck out” with a woman, but also an actor whose benevolent screen persona made it hard to process him doing something quite so nefarious.
The film was, however, directed by Adrian Lyne (Deep Water), who is basically to ‘sexy affairs’ what Kurosawa is to samurai or Martin Scorsese is to gangster movies. So, if erotic thrillers are your bag, you’ll probably vibe with it.
6. Showgirls (1995)
The third winner to make our list might be the most famous Razzie win of them all, at least partially because Paul Verhoeven (always a man with an eye for marketing his own brand) decided to treat it as a badge of honour by showing up to collect the award, the first of a few people to do so over the years.
Showgirls is the Dutch legend’s famously raunchy, weirdly acted, insanely expensive but totally singular follow-up to Basic Instinct—and if you like that movie, and erotic thrillers in general, you’ll probably get a kick out of it.
7. Armageddon (1988)
1998 turned out to be a banner year for weird decisions at the Razzies, with several popular movies making the cut in the “Worst Movie” category. Alongside Michael Bay’s entertainingly ridiculous and ridiculously entertaining Armageddon were the perfectly fun Spice World and Roland Emmerich’s silly but definitely not awful Godzilla movie.
It goes to show how much hindsight can do for a movie’s reputation. I’m sure most filmgoers reading this would probably die to see a summer containing those three movies right now.
8. The Blair Witch Project (1999)
Reading over 45 years of Razzie nominees, none surprised me as much as The Blair Witch Project, a daring, scary, original, formally inventive, wildly influential and phenomenally successful horror movie that many today (and even at the time) would agree is a modern classic of the genre—and a must-watch if you’re a fan of footage horror like Paranormal Activity.
The winner that year was the admittedly terrible Wild Wild West, but the inclusion of Adam Sandler’s enduring comedy Big Daddy and Star Wars: Episode 1 suggests the selection committee, much like the previous year, was especially off the mark.
9. White Chicks (2004)
Take even a cursory glance over the awards body’s history, and you’ll notice a few obvious trends. One is an apparent hatred for Sylvester Stallone, who has 12 nominations as well as a win for “Worst Actor of the Century” in 2000. Another trend is their (admittedly more understandable) distaste for modern spoof movies, mostly from the Marlon Wayans school of spoofery, though none of the ones that the Wayans wrote—like Don’t Be a Menace or anything from the Scary Movie franchise—were ever nominated.
What did make the cut is the Wayans bros.’ White Chicks, a comedy that not only survived its critical mauling at the time and made a bunch of money, but it has, in more recent years, been reappraised as a sharp work of social satire. It’s also a blast.
10. Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice (2016)
If this list looks a little pre-2010 heavy, there are a couple of reasons for that. Firstly, even these days, it still takes time for a film to be reappraised. The other is the simple fact that Hollywood became an industry of franchises around that time, which meant less interesting choices from the Razzies selection committee—take a look from 2010 on, and it’s basically a selection of whatever Twilight or Transformers movie happened to be released that year.
What you don’t see a whole lot of are superhero movies, aside from the glaringly obvious Fantastic Four fiasco. The committee did, however, nominate Zack Snyder’s Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice in 2016, a doom metal spectacle that, whatever you might make of it, is certainly the work of a singular artist. The “Martha” thing is still inexcusable, but it’s a deathly sincere movie that I’d recommend going back to to give another watch.




















































