The 8 Biggest Returning Shows In September 2026
There are few things as glorious as Fall TV. With new premieres like Neagley (2026) and the upcoming sequel series A Different World (2026), we’re also finally getting back in the swing of things with our favorite returning shows from various genres. The summer months always feel like they’re reserved for the bigger blockbusters, whereas everything about Fall TV is like cozying up at home as best as we can when the weather in various places is still so hot.
There are so many returning shows that keeping up with them at times is a wild adventure. From procedurals to newer comedies and even reality TV, there's always something for every type of viewer. Whether on network television or streamers like Netflix and Apple TV, here are some of the biggest shows returning in September 2026.
September 3
Two years after its premiere, Guy Ritchie's The Gentlemen is finally set to return for its second season on Netflix. The first left us with alliances seemingly in a good place, but the trailer indicates that everything's bound to be tested and challenged. It makes sense considering this is the norm for what Ritchie typically does with his movies, and it's bound to make everything bloodier while amping up the stakes.
Will there be a romance? Will there be character deaths? Will there be countless betrayals? I have a feeling we can count on that third one in the same way we can with The Traitors (2023). Still, if you love stylistic and intense crime dramas, now's the time to catch up and tune in to The Gentlemen ahead of Season 2.
September 9
The Paper, the surprisingly compelling spin-off of The Office (2005), is set to return for its second season, promising more hijinks, hilarious beats of breaking news, and judging by the trailers, a romance, too. Relationships aren't rare in sitcoms, but seeing it happen so early with Domhnall Gleeson's Ned and Chelsea Frei's Mare is incredibly refreshing.
It's not every spin-off that manages to be thrilling enough to garner care right off the bat, but that's exactly why The Paper works. It isn't trying to be The Office, nor is it trying to be any other mockumentary, even if it's taking familiar beats. There's a unique originality in the show and, in large part, it's entirely because journalism is such a rare job to see on TV that this detail alone makes the show a must-watch.
September 16
Slow Horses is one of the few streaming dramas that consistently releases a new season every year, proving that it can, in fact, be done. Sharp, riveting, and thoughtfully penned every time, it consistently shines as a brilliant adaptation of Mick Herron's bestselling novels. And judging by the Season 6 trailer, this chapter seems to be one of the most intense spectacles to date.
The season is also set to see the return of Olivia Cooke's Sid Baker, who hasn't been in the show since its debut, so it'll be compelling to see how it all happens and what it means for the characters involved. Countless fans have been waiting for this exact moment, which makes this season one of the most anticipated returns to date.
September 17
As with American Horror Story, Ian Brennan and Ryan Murphy return with another installment of the Monster anthology series. This time, we're set to see what happened with Lizzie Borden and the murders of Andrew and Abby Borden in Fall River. As with most of these series, Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story will likely embellish and fabricate some of what really happened in order to tell a more gripping story fit for TV.
It could be really great if viewers separate reality from the fictionalized version, or it could be a mess that leaves people questioning why it was made in the first place. There's really no telling which way it'll go and how people will feel about it, but either way, it's a great time for its release with spooky season and fans wanting darker TV that deals with true crime.
September 18
Outlander (2014) might have aired its final episode, but Outlander: Blood of My Blood is only just beginning. The prequel series that centers around Jamie and Claire's parents was incredible in its debut, so it's exciting to see what the series will do next to expand the story and give viewers even more lore to add to the never-ending list the show consistently provides its fans with.
With the rebellion in full swing and stakes higher than they were in Season 1, Season 2 is surely bound to get darker without losing an ounce of the romance that keeps people obsessed and glued to their screens. Simultaneously, the Scottish Highlands are always a gorgeous place to revisit, so in a sea of shows that don't take characters toward fields of green often, everything about the period piece is uniquely appealing in a way that makes it stand out.
September 24
Right on time for the spooky season, American Horror Story returns with some of its most exciting cast members. Season 13 will include returning actors Sarah Paulson, Evan Peters, Lily Rabe, and Jessica Lange, alongside some newcomers like Paul Anthony Kelly from Love Story: John F. Kennedy and Carolyn Bessette (2026). While the show continues to remain an anthology, this new season bringing returning actors is sure to act as some sort of crossover arc.
Understandably, most of the plot details are being kept under wraps, but eagle-eyed viewers can probably piece together exactly which bit of lore we're seeing in this return. Ryan Murphy has said to The Hollywood Reporter that this season is essentially his thank you to the fans who've continued to watch the show all these years, so that should make this season extra fun.
September 27
The Joel McHale-led comedy series returns for its fifth season, with what's sure to be another blast. As another comedy series with a unique plot like The Paper, Animal Control delivers plenty of laughs and excellent character journeys. The series ended its fourth season on such a high note that it's never been more exciting to go back.
With long-awaited relationships coming to fruition and narrative points reaching a satisfying climax, it'll be gratifying for fans to see what comes next. As one of the more underrated comedies on this list, it's also incredible to see that it's snagged renewals to get to this place and hopefully it can carry on with more clever stories.
Bundle HD
Bundle HD
Bundle HD
Bundle HD
September 30
Bill Lawrence's Scrubs revival was such a hit during its premiere that it's now returning for a second season. As with time, the series feels more grounded and mature, while effortlessly ensuring that everything about it works for the decade we're in. And really, if there was going to be a reboot, now really is the best time to do so with Lawrence's current roster.
It still has similar quirks fans of its original run fell in love with, and the show is as relatable as it's always been. Fun and genuinely well-written on all fronts, it'll be riveting to see how the second season challenges characters and delivers more growth in every area.
