Fictional killers who make us question our own moral compass are fascinating. We know we shouldn't root for them, and yet, when they're written with charisma and a strangely relatable humanity, we can't help ourselves. The most popular murderers often come with tragic back stories shaped by pain, obsession, or an unshakable sense of purpose, and that complexity is what keeps us watching.
Whether they're vigilantes, icons of horror, or psychologically fractured masterminds, if you're ready to confront your own complicated love for killer storytelling, these are the murderers worth meeting on platforms like Netflix, HBO Max, and Hulu. Remember, it's not about endorsing their criminal behavior. We are simply drawn to the why behind it.
Memory of a Killer (2026)
Based on De Zaak Alzheimer, a 2003 Belgian film, Memory of a Killer follows Angelo Doyle (Patrick Dempsey), a hitman who begins losing his memory after being diagnosed with early-onset Alzheimer's. As his condition worsens, he races against time to protect his daughter from the criminal underworld while tying up the violent loose ends of his past.
The series, which is currently in its first season, manages to find the perfect balance between brutal crime show and family drama. Angelo comes across as more of a tragic figure than a cold-blooded killer because his crimes are rooted in survival and protection, not cruelty, even when they're horrifying. It shares the same thematic DNA with The Bourne Identity (2002), making it perfect for viewers who love when action mixes with intimate character studies.
Child's Play (1988)
Child's Play begins after a dying serial killer, Charles Lee Ray (Brad Dourif), transfers his soul into a Good Guy doll using voodoo magic. The seemingly innocent doll ends up in the hands of six-year-old Andy Barclay (Alex Vincent), who believes Chucky is his new best friend. When the doll goes on a mini killing spree while searching for a new body to possess, Andy has to convince his mother of its evil intent.
The horror of Child's Play lies in the contrast between Chucky's harmless-looking exterior and his adult cruelty. After several sequels and a series, Chucky became a fan favorite because his humor and lack of remorse make him unpredictable and weirdly endearing. The movie is great for viewers who like their horror with a good dose of mischievous energy.
The Silence of the Lambs (1991)
The Silence of the Lambs follows trainee FBI agent Clarice Starling (Jodie Foster), who has the terrifying task of interviewing Hannibal Lecter (Anthony Hopkins), an imprisoned cannibalistic serial killer, in hopes of catching another murderer. What begins as a professional exchange quickly becomes a psychological duel, as Hannibal uses manipulation to probe Clarice's deepest fears.
This film remains one of the most intelligent psychological thrillers ever made. We love Hannibal Lecter because his calm sophistication makes his brutality feel even more terrifying. It carries the same cerebral menace as Zodiac (2007), but with a far more intimate and personal power struggle. It's a must for fans of frightening character-driven suspense.
Scream (1996)
Scream tells the story of high school student Sidney Prescott (Neve Campbell), who, along with her friends, becomes the target of a serial killer called Ghostface. On the anniversary of her mother's murder, Ghostface turns his murderous spree into a game by taunting his victims with horror movie trivia before killing them. The film cleverly plays with genre expectations, turning familiar tropes into punchlines and weapons.
Everyone eventually becomes a suspect as Scream turns the classic slasher movie formula into a self-aware commentary on fear and storytelling. Ghostface is popular because the mask makes the killer feel more like an idea instead of a single person. The movie is ideal for horror fans who love a few good jump scares and self-referential plots.
Dexter (2006-2013)
Dexter follows a forensic analyst, Dexter Morgan (Michael C. Hall), who secretly lives a double life as a serial killer targeting other murderers. Guided by a strict moral code he learned from his adoptive father, he channels his dark urges into what he believes is a form of justice. Each season explores how long he can maintain the illusion of normalcy before his worlds collide.
Dexter thrives on its psychological character work, which is why we are drawn to Dexter. His internal conflict makes him feel oddly relatable, and there's also a twisted satisfaction in watching someone who operates outside the law deliver consequences where the system fails. The series feels like a darker, more introspective cousin to You (2018) and is ideal for fans of long-form crime storytelling.
Bates Motel (2013-2017)
Bates Motel is a modern reimagining of Psycho (1960). The series chronicles the early life of Norman Bates (Freddie Highmore) and his intense co-dependent relationship with his mother, Norma (Vera Farmiga). The series tracks his slow psychological unraveling as his fractured identity begins to take shape, while his mother does everything in her power to protect him.
The brightest part of the series is how it humanizes a character we already know will become monstrous. Norman becomes an endearing character due to his initial clueless vulnerability. So when he turns into a killer, you're left feeling a little sad rather than terrified. Bates Motel is the perfect series for anyone who enjoys psychological horror with a strong emotional arc.
Based on a True Story (2023-2024)
Based on a True Story follows Ava (Kaley Cuoco) and Nathan Bartlett (Chris Messina), a couple under intense financial strain, who become obsessed with the popularity of true crime podcasts just as a serial killer resurfaces in their neighborhood. When they cross paths with Matt Pierce (Tom Bateman), who may be responsible for the murders, their curiosity quickly turns into a dangerous opportunity.
Based on a True Story is a smart mix of satire and suspense. We find ourselves rooting for Matt because he's charismatic (in a disturbing way), revealing just how easily charm can override common sense. Even more unsettling is how he exposes the protagonists' own moral decay. It's perfect for fans of Only Murders in the Building (2021) and viewers who enjoy thrillers that critique media culture.
