Ryan Coolger's 'The X-Files' Reboot Will Fail Without One Thing

The X-Files (1993) is coming back in a different package. Ryan Coogler's long-teased reboot finally has some concrete details, including a confirmed Hulu pilot and an official lead in Danielle Deadwyler, who you might know from projects like Till (2022) and Station 11 (2021). However, Deadwyler is only one half of a pair. Following in the footsteps of the original series, Coogler's The X-Files reboot will feature "two highly decorated but vastly different FBI agents" who, presumably, pick up where Scully and Mulder left off in the basement office. 

This is where casting will play a pivotal role in the success of The X-Files reboot. While viewers tuned in weekly for the aliens, monsters, and supernatural oddities the show offered, it was ultimately Scully, Mulder, and their intense relationship that kept them glued to the screen. Replicating the chemistry between actors Gillian Anderson and David Duchovny will be no easy feat, and if Coogler fumbles with casting, his reboot might flop. 

'The X-Files' Worked Because Of Scully And Mulder

When The X-Files debuted in 1993, there wasn't anything on TV quite like it at the time. It dared to delve into conspiracies and corruption within the US government like no other show would, and when everyone's favorite FBI agents weren't staring down shadowy syndicate figures, they were investigating supernatural phenomena in the spirit of Kolchak: The Night Stalker (1974) and The Twilight Zone (1959). However, Scully and Mulder lent the series its heart. 

Despite their skeptic/believer dynamic, the two hit it off immediately and never failed to show each other the utmost respect. Their opposing views didn't turn them into enemies. Instead, it helped balance them. Perhaps, more importantly, their relationship subverted gender roles in a way that wasn't common in the '90s. Scully got to be a grounded, capable woman who relied on science and logic, while Mulder embraced his more impulsive, big-feeling nature. 

They're easy characters to fall in love with, and truthfully, The X-Files only lasted as long as it did because of them. Duchovny's departure for (most of) Season 8 and 9 hurt the show. Fans still loved the world Chris Carter created, but it became clear the series' real draw was Scully and Mulder together. They are undoubtedly two of the most important (and iconic) characters in pop culture history. So much of that boils down to Gillian Anderson and David Duchovny's performances and chemistry, which means the reboot's success boils down to the casting. 

'The X-Files' Reboot Needs To Consider Chemistry 

Many have described Anderson and Duchovny's chemistry as "lightning in a bottle," something near impossible to replicate. And personally, I agree. As someone who watches a lot of TV, I've never seen two actors look at each other the way Anderson and Duchovny do. If you disagree, I implore you to go watch the "Pilot" right now with fresh eyes, because it's that unexplainable magic between them that adds another layer of nuance to Scully and Mulder. 

At the time of writing, it's unknown who will play opposite Deadwyler in The X-Files reboot, or how closely these new FBI agents will skew to Scully and Mulder's skeptic/believer archetypes. However, it's likely longtime fans of the series, like myself, will compare this new pairing to the original. And truthfully, how could you not? If I were Coogler, I'd be more worried about how well Deadwyler and her future co-star vibe more than anything else. 

Anyone carrying on The X-Files mantle will hopefully demonstrate a similar complimentary nature and respect for each. Yet, there's also a chance that sticking too close to Mulder and Scully's dynamic could create its own issues. 

Is It A Mistake For The Reboot To Follow Scully And Mulder's Dynamic Too Closely?

Keep things the same, or change it up? This is the tricky balancing act that any reboot has to consider, and it's usually a lose-lose scenario. Some people expect a reboot to capture the same spirit of the original, while others crave something different and see following in the original's footsteps too closely as unoriginality. Coogler's The X-Files project has a lot to consider in that regard. 

Will watching another skeptic/believer dynamic feel like too much of a Mulder/Scully retread? Will these new characters follow a similar slow-burn, friends-to-lovers relationship, or will Coogler decide to ditch romance entirely? Will trust be the number one thing that binds them together, or will Coogler find a new catalyst for their bond? Hey, there's even a chance these characters start more in animosity territory, although I think that would be a mistake. 

Without more information, your guesses to these questions are as good as mine. With Coogler's unprecedented 16 Oscar nominations for Sinners (2026), he currently ranks as one of the most decorated Black directors in history. There's no doubt the man knows how to make great cinema. Here's hoping he can apply that same prowess and detail to TV and revive one of pop culture's greatest series ever made.